Learn to Be Lonely

Opening artwork for Learn to Be Lonely
A wolf mask beneath a moonlit sky

Tonight, I reached for a hand that wasn’t there.

I didn’t mean to.

That may be the part that undid me most.

I was sitting in a crowded theater surrounded by couples, watching Phantom of the Opera, when my hand moved slightly toward the empty space beside me.

Not dramatically.

Not even consciously.

Just the small, ordinary movement of someone whose body expected to find someone there.

And then I remembered.

He isn’t here.

For a while, I thought perhaps I was reaching for my phone.

That would make sense.

For now, the phone has become a strange substitute for a hand.

It is where his face appears.

Where his voice lives.

Where good morning and goodnight have crossed thousands of miles.

Where I have learned the geography of another human being without ever having touched him.

In a strange way, it is where our hands have been meeting.

But sitting there tonight, I realized something else.

I was reaching for him.

And I cannot remember doing that before.

Not really.

I have loved people.

I have had partners.

I have walked through crowded parks and sat in theaters and slept beside other bodies.

But I do not remember my hand instinctively searching for theirs.

Somewhere very early, I learned not to reach.

There were lessons.

You’re ugly.

You don’t have talent.

You’re strange.

Too much.

Wrong somehow.

And beneath all of them was another lesson, rarely spoken quite so plainly:

No one is coming.

So learn to be lonely.

Learn to find your way in darkness.

Learn to be your own companion.

Learn how to love a life lived alone.

And I did.

God, I did.

I became remarkably good at it.

I built gates.

Beautiful ones.

Complicated ones.

The kind constructed by someone who has spent a lifetime studying exactly where things break.

When emotion became dangerous, I could close them with the precision of a skilled machinist.

Click.

Lock.

Safe.

I learned how to make shelter out of almost anything.

A car.

A cello.

A room with the light left on.

Words.

Music.

My own two hands.

I became so capable of surviving alone that sometimes I mistook survival for preference.

And yet there was another image I carried with me.

I had almost forgotten how long I have carried it.

When I was younger, I watched The Village and saw Ivy Walker walk into the woods.

She was blind.

There were things in those woods she had been taught to fear. Monsters, she believed, lived somewhere inside the darkness.

And still she went.

I remember her hands most of all.

Stretched out in front of her.

Reaching.

She could not see what was coming.

She could not know whether the next thing her fingers found would be a branch, a tree, another human being, or something she had been taught all her life to fear.

But she reached anyway.

That image lodged itself somewhere very deep in me.

Through events in my own life, when I was frightened and could not see what came next, I would remember her.

Hands out.

Keep moving.

For years, I think I understood the image as courage.

And it was.

But sitting in that theater tonight, I realized there was something else inside it too.

Ivy does not reach because she is certain the woods are safe.

She reaches because reaching is how she finds her way through the dark.

Perhaps some part of me learned that alongside all the other lessons.

While one voice was teaching me:

Learn to be lonely.

Something quieter was saying:

Put your hands out.

So perhaps the gates were never the whole story.

Perhaps even while I was learning how not to need anyone, there remained a little boy somewhere inside me walking through his own dark woods with his hands stretched in front of him.

Still searching.

Still believing there might be something beyond what he could see.

And then someone arrived.

Impossibly far away.

And somehow, in a very short time, he began opening gates I had forgotten were gates.

Not by forcing them.

By returning.

A face in the morning.

A voice at night.

A ridiculous joke.

A song.

A confession.

A promise of another call.

Another tomorrow.

Tiny repetitions that began teaching my body something my mind had never quite believed:

You can reach.

Someone may reach back.

And apparently my body believed him.

Because tonight my hand moved before the gatekeeper could stop it.

It simply reached for the person it had learned belonged there.

And when I realized what I had done, I cried.

Because suddenly I wasn’t only missing him.

I was watching that little boy again.

Except this time he wasn’t reaching into the darkness simply to find his way through it.

He was reaching because, somewhere along the way, he had learned to expect a hand.

And there was something almost unbearable about that.

Something beautiful, too.

The child who had been taught learn to be lonely had somehow learned another lesson.

Someone might be there.

And when there wasn’t a hand there tonight, part of me wanted to run toward him and pull him back.

To build the gates again.

Quickly.

Before this becomes another wound.

Before he learns the old lesson all over again.

See?

This is what happens when you reach.

Learn to be lonely.

But I couldn’t do that to him.

Not again.

So somewhere during the music, with tears I couldn’t quite stop, I put my hands over my stomach.

I don’t know why I put them there.

My body chose the place.

And suddenly I understood:

I was still reaching.

Only this time, my hands had turned toward him.

Toward the little boy who had been walking through the woods all these years.

Hands out.

Trying to find his way.

So I took his hand.

Not to lead him out of the woods.

Not to tell him there were no monsters.

Not to promise him that the person he loves will be waiting when the trees finally open.

I cannot promise him any of those things.

I simply wanted him to know:

This time, when you reach into the dark, someone is here.

Me.

And somewhere inside me, a conversation began.

I’m sorry.

For what?

That you finally reached and there was no hand there.

Silence.

Then:

But there was.

And I knew what he meant.

There had been a hand.

Again and again.

That is why he learned to reach.

Someone had reached back enough times that this frightened little creature inside me had begun to believe hands might be for holding instead of guarding.

Absence does not erase that.

Silence does not erase that.

Whatever comes next cannot make the reaching foolish.

And then I remembered something else about Ivy.

She didn’t only use her hands to find her way through the woods.

There was a moment when she simply held one out.

She could not see the person coming toward her.

She had no proof, in that moment, that anyone would meet her there.

She just kept her hand extended.

And then—

a hand.

Someone was there.

Maybe that is the image I need now.

Because there is a part of me that still believes the person I love will be there.

I say that carefully.

Not as prophecy.

Not as a bargain with the universe.

Not because loving someone hard enough guarantees their return.

I know too much about life to confuse hope with certainty.

But I also know what has already happened between us.

I reached.

He reached back.

Again.

And again.

And again.

Enough times that somewhere inside me, reaching stopped feeling like a question.

My hand simply began expecting his.

Perhaps that is why it moved beside me in the theater before I had time to think.

It remembered.

So I don’t want to teach it fear again.

I don’t want this silence to become another mother whispering:

See?

You should have learned to be lonely.

I want to let my hand remember something else.

His hand has been there.

His voice has been there.

His face has appeared from thousands of miles away.

He has found me in the dark before.

And I am allowed to hope he will again.

So perhaps, for now, I can be Ivy.

Standing at the edge of everything I cannot see.

One hand extended into the darkness.

Not grasping.

Not chasing.

Not demanding that the woods give me an answer.

Just reaching.

With that strange little knowing hope that somewhere beyond what I can see,

he is still making his way toward me.

And with my other hand,

I will hold the little boy.

Because he is frightened.

Because he remembers every time reaching hurt.

Because this time I refuse to make him choose between hope and protection.

He can have both.

One hand for himself.

One hand for the person he loves.

And if he asks me what happens next,

I will tell him the truth.

I don’t know, sweetheart.

But we don’t have to pull our hand back yet.

He has found it before.

Let’s leave it here a little longer.

Maybe that is enough for tonight.

A theater.

A masquerade.

A wolf mask bought because I thought it would make someone I love smile.

An empty place beside me.

A hand that forgot, for one beautiful, terrible second, that it had ever learned to be afraid.

And another hand that found it.

Mine.

So perhaps this is what I will teach the little boy instead.

Not how to be lonely.

How to remain.

How to sit beside himself when the person he loves cannot be reached.

How to let the gates stay open without standing defenseless at them.

How to hope without turning hope into a promise.

How to reach without abandoning himself in the reaching.

How to say:

I saw you reach.

I know how brave that was.

You were not foolish.

Someone really did reach back.

And I will not punish you for having loved him.

I don’t know how this story ends.

That is perhaps the hardest sentence I know how to write tonight.

The part of me that reads the last page first desperately wants to know.

It wants to prepare us.

It wants to turn uncertainty into grief because grief, at least, has a shape.

But tonight I am trying not to write an ending that has not happened.

Tonight, I will stand with that little boy at the edge of the woods.

One of my hands holding his.

The other stretched into everything I cannot see.

Hands out.

Heart open.

Not because there are no monsters in the woods.

Not because I know the ending.

But because after a lifetime of learning how to be lonely,

something in me has finally learned

to believe there might be a hand

reaching back.

And perhaps when the little boy becomes frightened and asks if we should pull our hand back now,

I will squeeze the one I am holding and tell him:

Not yet, sweetheart.

He has found us before.

Let’s leave it here a little longer.