THE MOTIONS
The Choreography of Grief
CJ Sterling | The Light We Leave On

There is a peculiar cruelty in discovering that the world does not stop when yours does.
The pumpkins still need carving.
The children still need feeding.
Someone has homework.
And somewhere, beneath the ordinary architecture of an October afternoon, an entire universe is coming apart.
I am standing in the kitchen.
There are pumpkin seeds on the counter. A spoon in the sink. The peculiar, damp smell of Halloween beginning to take shape.
One of the boys calls me over.
I look at what he's made.
And I mean it when I tell him how wonderful it is.
That's the part I wish people understood.
The joy is real, too.
I am not pretending to love these moments. I love them.
I love the ridiculous concentration on their faces. The negotiations over pumpkin teeth. The solemn engineering decisions involved in determining whether a triangle is sufficiently frightening.
I am there.

Entirely there.
Until suddenly I am not.
Something moves inside my chest.
Not a thought, exactly.
More like a structural failure.
A load-bearing wall giving way somewhere no one can see.
I excuse myself.
Bathroom.
Door.
Hands on the sink.
I grip the porcelain so tightly my knuckles begin to whiten.
And for a moment, I don't understand why.
Then I do.
Oh.
I'm holding on.
Not simply to keep myself standing.
I'm holding the sink the way I wish I could hold his hand.
As though, if I squeeze hard enough, something might squeeze back.
But porcelain has never learned how to hold someone.
And there is something almost unbearable about discovering that even my hands are grieving.
They have spent so much of my life learning what to do.
How to work. How to protect. How to comfort. How to carry.
And now they are asking for something so terribly simple.
Another hand.
His.
And then—
Oh, God.
There you are.
Or rather, there you aren't.
And the difference is enough to bring me to my knees.
I cry with a depth that surprises me, although by now I should be accustomed to the extraordinary things a human body can do when it cannot reach someone it loves.
My throat closes.
My chest contracts.
My face becomes unfamiliar.
I turn on the faucet.
Cold water.
Once.
Twice.
I look in the mirror.
The man looking back is attempting to negotiate with his own nervous system.
We have to go back.
There are pumpkins.
There are children.
There is dinner.
Water.
Breathe.
Again.
I return.
Someone asks where the pumpkin candle went.
I find it.
Someone needs help.
I help.
Someone makes a joke, and I laugh.
A real laugh.
Imagine that.
A human being can be breaking into a thousand pieces and still find something genuinely funny.
I wonder whether the heart knows how absurd this is.
Whether it understands that I am asking it to perform two entirely different lives simultaneously.
Love someone who is absent.
Love everyone who is present.
Keep beating.
Don't make a scene.
Remember the homework.
I start dinner.
I peel the apples.
There is something almost obscene about the competence of my hands.
They know what to do.
They have been making meals for years.
They do not need my permission to continue.
Chop.
Stir.
Turn down the heat.
Check the oven.
And then—
The sun.
Through the window.
A memory.
That extraordinary quiet when we would finally find each other and breathe together.
My hand stops.
The apple falls.

I cannot remember what I was doing.
For a moment, I cannot remember how to be a person standing in a kitchen.
Only how to be someone who misses him.
So much.
So terribly much.
I leave the room.
Again.
And this time the tears come before I reach the bathroom.
I try to contain them.
What a ridiculous word.
Contain.
As though grief were water in a glass rather than an ocean discovering that the walls of the house are made of paper.
I bend over the sink.
My body takes over the telling.
Heartbeat.
Breath.
Pause.
Tears.
Breath.
No.
Not yet.
Again.
Water.
Face.
Hands.
The mirror.
I don't recognize the expression.
But I recognize the instructions.
Return.
There are people waiting.
And so I do.
I check the food.
I ask about homework.
I admire another pumpkin.
I remind someone to wash their hands.
I find a missing shoe.
I am a functioning adult.
Astonishing.
Someone should award me a certificate.
Congratulations. You successfully located the cinnamon while experiencing the collapse of your known universe.
I might even frame it.
If I could stop crying long enough to find a hammer.
And there it is again.
A laugh.
A sob.
Sometimes so close together I cannot tell which one has arrived.
I have spent a lifetime learning the choreography of holding things together.
Step into the kitchen.
Smile.
Turn.
Remember the homework.
Step into the bathroom.
Close the door.
Break.
Water.
Breathe.
Return.
Again.
Again.
There is a rhythm to it now.
A terrible, practiced rhythm.
And I know every step.
Except the one my body keeps trying to make.
The one toward you.
I think about the way we used to breathe together. How the frantic, discordant music of our separate days would suddenly become quiet when we found each other.
Two people.
One breath.
And now I am dancing with an absence.
My hands still remember where his should be.
My body keeps turning toward someone it cannot reach.
There is a space beside me that no amount of movement can close.
And still, I know the steps.
Release.
Straighten my shirt.
Open the door.
Return.
Because somewhere in the other room, a child is calling.
And the music has not stopped.
But nobody taught me what to do when the thing coming apart is not a situation, or a relationship, or a plan.
When it is the future.
The one you had finally allowed yourself to imagine.
The ordinary mornings.
The ridiculous conversations.
The possibility of hearing someone moving through another room and knowing you could simply walk toward them.
No intermediary.
No danger.
No permission required.
Just love.
Just a life.
And now I am standing in a kitchen trying to remember whether I put salt in the potatoes.
This is what grief looks like when it has responsibilities.
Not a beautiful woman staring through a rain-streaked window.
Not a man collapsing theatrically in an empty street.
Sometimes it looks like a grown man with pumpkin on his sleeve, asking a child whether he's finished his homework while his own heart is begging for someone who cannot answer.
And perhaps the most astonishing thing is that neither experience cancels the other.
The child deserves his Halloween.
I deserve to miss the person I love.
The dinner deserves not to burn.
My heart deserves to break.
All of these things are true.
All at once.
And there is no elegant way to arrange them.
Only the motions.
The chronology of an ordinary afternoon.
A pumpkin.
A laugh.
A memory.
A bathroom.
Water.
A sob.
A breath.
A child calling from the other room.
Coming.
I'm coming.
One moment.
Just—
One—
Breath.
And again.
And again.
Until the door opens.

And I return to the people I love.
Still carrying the person I miss.
Still coming apart.
Still here.
And somewhere inside my chest, beneath the terrible exhaustion, beneath the words I cannot say aloud, beneath everything that has been taken from the future I imagined—
Heartbeat.
Breath.
Heartbeat.
Breath.
I love you.
Heartbeat.
Breath.
I miss you.
And again.