The River

Two chairs beside a misty river at sunrise

For years, I believed there was something about me that made people leave once they were well.

I did not believe this casually.

I had evidence.

Or what I thought was evidence.

People came close when they were hurting.

When they were lost.

When they were frightened.

When they needed someone to listen long enough for the room to stop spinning.

When they needed light.

I knew how to do that.

I knew how to become steady.

How to make space.

How to hold what other people could not hold by themselves.

And often, once the crisis passed, something changed.

The calls became less frequent.

The urgency disappeared.

Their lives widened again.

Sometimes they left completely.

And each time, some part of me quietly concluded:

There it is.

Again.

I was needed.

I was not wanted.

Years ago, someone I loved and revered told me that I was a river.

She said people would come when they were thirsty.

That they would come when they needed healing.

When their hearts and minds and bodies needed refreshing.

And in the years since, this is how I have remembered it:

They would kneel at the edge of me.

Wash their wounds.

Cup their hands.

Take what they needed.

And leave.

Because nothing could stay in the river without drowning.

No one could stay.

So I would have to learn to be okay with that.

I know she meant it lovingly.

Maybe she meant movement.

Maybe she meant purpose.

Maybe she meant that some people are called to accompany others through transformation.

But what I heard was:

No one stays.

No one will stay.

And because I trusted her, I carried it like prophecy.

For years, I believed this was wisdom.

Every departure became proof.

Every person who found themselves and then found someone else became proof.

Every relationship that changed once I was no longer necessary became proof.

So I became very good at being water.

I flowed toward people.

I carried.

I softened.

I made room.

I refreshed.

I soothed.

I learned how to hold what other people could not.

I made myself useful.

And usefulness can look an awful lot like intimacy.

Sometimes it is intimacy.

But they are not the same thing.

I know what it feels like to be needed.

I know what it feels like to be the person someone calls when the world is ending.

I know what it feels like to be trusted with the thing they have never told anyone.

I know what it feels like to be depended upon.

I know what it feels like to be used.

To be objectified.

To be admired for what I can provide.

To be loved, even.

But lately I have been asking myself a question I do not know how to answer.

Do I know what it feels like to be wanted?

Not wanted because I am useful.

Not wanted because I can help.

Not wanted because I make pain easier to carry.

Wanted in the useless way.

The ordinary way.

The almost embarrassingly simple way.

I do not need anything.

I just wanted to hear your voice.

Nothing happened.

I just thought of you.

Come sit here.

Stay.

Tell me that story again.

Lie beside me.

I do not need to be saved.

I just prefer the world when you are in the room.

That kind of wanting.

The kind that does not have a problem attached to it.

The kind that does not require me to earn my place by being good at holding someone else’s pain.

When I was seventeen, I was in a musical.

I wore prosthetics.

Every night, one of the techs carefully put them on my face.

And every night, he carefully took them off.

He was someone I knew from school.

Not someone I was especially close to.

There was no romance.

No sex.

No crisis.

No declaration.

Just his hands.

Careful.

Gentle.

Close.

He did not need anything from me.

I did not have to perform tenderness back.

I could simply sit there and receive it.

More than twenty years later, I told him how much that had meant to me.

I think some part of me understood, even then, that my body had kept that memory because it was rare.

There are moments when the body understands something before the mind does.

A small kindness.

A brief touch.

Nothing dramatic.

And yet the body notices.

Not because it wants something from the person offering it.

Because it remembers what tenderness feels like.

It has been years since I have been held with any regularity.

Long enough that even a small gesture can move through me like weather.

And I am beginning to understand that loneliness is not always a thought.

Sometimes it is skin.

Sometimes it is a body quietly realizing how long it has gone without being held.

A hand resting in the river, with words about being needed and longing to be wanted

I am starting to understand something difficult.

The choices other people make are not always evaluations of my worth.

Someone can love me and still reach for attention.

For substances.

For novelty.

For validation.

For some other source of relief that touches a place in them I cannot reach.

That does not necessarily mean I failed.

It may not mean anything about me at all.

But this is also true:

Something can have nothing to do with my worth and still hurt me.

Someone can love me and still leave me lonely.

Someone can choose me in some ways and fail to choose me in others.

Someone can come because I soothe them.

Someone can love what I give.

Someone can rest at my banks

and still never learn the sound of me.

Understanding why a person reaches elsewhere does not automatically make the emptiness disappear.

And compassion for someone else’s wound does not require abandoning my own.

That may be the piece I have missed.

I have spent so much of my life asking:

Why am I not enough to make them stay?

Why am I not enough to make them stop reaching elsewhere?

Why am I not enough to be chosen?

Maybe those questions were built on the wrong premise.

Maybe another person’s hunger was never proof of my insufficiency.

Maybe I was never supposed to be enough to fill every empty room inside another human being.

Maybe no one is.

But I am allowed to ask something different now.

Not:

How can I become enough?

But:

What do I need in order to feel wanted?

What does being chosen actually look like to me?

Does it look like someone reaching first?

Making time?

Calling when nothing is wrong?

Wanting the ordinary Tuesday?

Wanting my body near theirs?

Wanting my thoughts even when they are inconvenient?

Wanting my company when there are a thousand brighter things available?

Maybe I do not need someone to choose me instead of everything.

Maybe I need to know what it feels like to be chosen among everything.

That is different.

And maybe even that is not the whole question.

Because I have spent so much time asking whether someone chooses me that I have not always asked whether I choose them.

Not because they need me.

Not because I understand their pain.

Not because I can explain why they behave as they do.

Not because I am afraid that leaving would make me cruel.

But because the relationship itself nourishes me.

Because I can breathe there.

Because I do not have to keep auditioning for my place.

Because love is not only something I pour outward.

Because I am allowed to ask whether their way of loving creates somewhere I can actually live.

That question is harder.

Who comes to me because they are thirsty?

And who has learned the sound of my water?

Who loves what I provide?

And who is curious about who I am when I have nothing to give?

Who reaches for me in catastrophe?

And who remembers me in the ordinary hour?

Who sits near the water without asking it to become useful?

Who stays through flood?

Through drought?

Through mud?

Through stillness?

Who wants not only the water,

but a life beside it?

When did understanding someone become the same thing as accepting what hurts me?

How much of my life have I spent asking whether I am being chosen without asking whether I am choosing back?

What if being wanted is not enough?

What if the deeper longing is to be considered?

To be made room for?

To be remembered when nothing is wrong?

What does love have to look like before my body can finally stop auditioning for it?

And if I stopped trying to prove that I was worth staying for,

who would I still choose to stay beside?

Perhaps this is where the river changes meaning.

Maybe I was never a river people could not stay beside.

Maybe I simply became very skilled at flowing toward people who were thirsty.

Maybe I mistook the people who came to drink for the people who came to stay.

Maybe sometimes it was love.

Maybe sometimes it was both.

But rivers are not only crossed.

They are not only used.

People build homes beside rivers.

They learn the sound of them in winter.

They sit near them when they are not thirsty.

They bring chairs.

They watch the light move across the water.

They return when they need nothing.

They stay long enough to know the river in flood.

In drought.

In mud.

In stillness.

They do not love it only when it is beautiful.

They do not ask it to be useful every day.

A chair and blanket beside the river at sunset, with words about the river having a choice

And the river, too, gets to choose.

Which banks feel safe.

Which homes feel warm.

Which footsteps it has learned.

Which people come only to take.

Which people come to stay.

Which people know how to sit nearby without asking for anything.

Which people make the river feel less like a resource

and more like a place.

And there is something else I am finally beginning to understand.

I do not have to become less river.

I do not have to become shallow so someone will remain.

I do not have to dam myself.

Make myself smaller.

Flow more quietly.

Need less.

Feel less.

Give less depth to the parts of me that have always run deep.

And I do not have to spend the rest of my life becoming more useful

and calling that being loved.

I do not know yet what it would feel like to trust another kind of staying.

But I know this now.

I want to learn the difference.

Between being needed.

Being loved.

Being wanted.

And being chosen.

I want to learn the difference between someone wanting access to the river

and someone wanting a life beside it.

And maybe the river was never meant to learn how to be alone.

Maybe it was only meant to stop believing that solitude was the price of being deep.

Maybe the prophecy was never:

No one can stay.

Maybe it was:

Learn who knows how.

And then choose them, too.