The Light We Leave OnWriting by CJ Sterling

There Was No Gate

There Was No Gate. On the Watchman, the little boy, and the day protection learned to recognize love.
For much of my life, there was a Watchman.

He lived somewhere inside me, in a place built long before I understood what safety was supposed to feel like.

He knew the sound of approaching footsteps.

He knew how quickly a familiar voice could become something frightening.

He knew that love, when offered by the wrong hands, could become another word for danger.

And so he built walls.

Not because he hated the world.

But because there was a little boy behind them who had already learned what happened when nobody was watching.
The Watchman took his work seriously.

He studied every visitor.

He listened for changes in tone.

He learned to recognize the weather in another person’s face.

And when someone approached with tenderness, he did not immediately open the door.

He looked for the storm hiding behind it.

For years, I mistook his vigilance for the whole of who I was.

Eventually, I began to understand that he had never been the enemy.

He was a part of me that had accepted an impossible responsibility.

Keep the little boy safe.

At any cost.
And because he had been given so little help, he had learned to build a fortress around everything the boy loved.

There were gates.

There were walls.

There was a moat, deep enough to make approaching difficult and crossing almost unthinkable.

And somewhere inside, a little boy watched the world through a window.

He wanted to be loved.

Of course he did.

But wanting had become dangerous.

And so the Watchman guarded even that.
For years, whenever something beautiful approached, the Watchman stood between it and the boy.

Like Gandalf at the edge of an ancient bridge, facing the darkness with his staff raised.

You shall not pass.

He said it to danger.

He said it to betrayal.

He said it to every approaching possibility that resembled something which had once caused pain.

And sometimes, without meaning to, he said it to love.

Because when your earliest lessons teach you that tenderness may conceal harm, even the things you have prayed for can begin to resemble things you must defend against.
The Watchman did not know how to tell the difference.

Not always.

And so he chose caution.

He chose distance.

He chose another night of watching.

And the boy remained behind him.

Safe from some things.

Separated from others.

Longing for a world he could see but could not quite reach.

Over the years, I learned to sit beside the Watchman.

To recognize the difference between danger and the memory of danger.
To thank him for what he had done without allowing him to decide what every new encounter meant.

Slowly, he began learning another way of being.

He could witness.

He could look at something beautiful without immediately searching for what might destroy it.

He could allow the little boy to enjoy a moment without requiring him to prepare for its ending.

But even then, the armor remained close.

The breastplate.

The familiar weight.

The comfort of knowing that if danger approached, he could stand between the boy and the world.
And then something happened that I still do not entirely know how to explain.

My heart opened to a family in Gaza.

And as affection began making its quiet home inside me, so did the people who had inspired it.

The family.

Their voices.

Their laughter.

Their worries.

Their small, ordinary hopes.

They did not arrive all at once.

They arrived in moments.

A mother’s kindness.

A sister’s tenderness.

A father’s welcome.
The sound of a family making room for someone they had never met in person.

And one afternoon, while a lullaby for Palestine played in my room, I watched a father and his son pray.

They were on the left side of my screen.

Thousands of miles away.

They had one prayer mat.

Just one.

And so they shared it.

I watched them move through the familiar gestures of their faith.

Their bodies bending toward the earth.

Their movements carrying something passed from one generation into the next.
I did not know every word.

I did not need to.

I knew what it meant to reach toward something sacred.

I knew what ritual could hold when life had become too uncertain for ordinary language.

And there, before me, was a father and son sharing a small place upon which to pray.

I thought about how much they had lost.

How little the world had left them.

But I did not want to turn their deprivation into a beautiful metaphor.

They deserved more than one prayer mat.

They deserved safety.

They deserved a home where their belongings could simply be belongings, rather than the fragile remains of everything they had managed to keep.
The beauty was not in what had been taken from them.

The beauty was theirs.

It lived in their relationship.

In their faith.

In the room they made for one another.

They had one mat.

And still, there was room for both of them.

And somewhere inside me, the Watchman was quiet.

Not absent.

Not defeated.

Simply quiet.
He had not sounded an alarm.

He had not demanded that I search the moment for its hidden danger.

He had allowed the boy to watch.

To listen.

To feel the tenderness of what was happening.

And when I looked toward the old fortress, I noticed something extraordinary.

There was no moat.

No bridge.

No gate.

Not for them.

And nobody had broken in.

They had simply been welcomed.
I had not needed to make myself smaller to love them.

I had not needed to surrender my own beliefs to honor theirs.

I had not needed to earn a place in their lives by becoming indispensable.

And perhaps most astonishingly, I had not needed to make them prove that every future moment would be safe before allowing myself to cherish this one.

They were already inside.

Not because they had been promised permanent exemption from the ordinary uncertainties of human relationships.

But because affection had been allowed to grow without being mistaken for an approaching storm.
And then I felt something rise in my chest that was much closer to tears.

Because there is something extraordinary about being invited into another person’s ordinary life.

Not through grand promises.

Not through declarations of belonging.

But through a recipe.

Through the way a father teaches something he knows.

Through the familiar certainty that there is, apparently, a correct way to make hummus, and that I am going to learn it.

And I thought about all the years I spent believing love was something I had to earn by being useful.

By anticipating needs.

By giving more.
By becoming the person who could hold everyone else’s burdens without asking anyone to hold mine.

I had become very good at giving away the light I helped cultivate.

And somewhere along the way, I had mistaken that giving for the price of being allowed to belong.

Yet here was someone offering me something I had not asked him to give.

Knowledge.

Tradition.

A little piece of home.

A place, however small, inside the ordinary rituals of his family.

And he was offering it with such ease.

No ceremony.

No obligation.

Just the promise of presence.
I wonder whether that is sometimes how belonging announces itself.

Not with a key placed dramatically into our hands.

But with someone asking whether we know how to make dinner.

With someone laughing because we have been preparing a familiar dish entirely the wrong way.

With the ordinary assumption that there will be another conversation.

Another lesson.

Another day.

And perhaps the Watchman heard that, too.

Not a guarantee.

Not a promise that nothing could ever hurt us.

But the sound of someone making room.
And then I began to understand why the tears were so close.

It was not only the prayer.

Not only the mat.

Not only the extraordinary tenderness of a father offering to teach me something from his home.

It was the safety.

Which is such a strange thing to say.

Because the people I love are living in a place where safety has become something terribly uncertain.

Where the night still requires listening.

Where even ordinary plans can be interrupted by danger.

And yet, here I am, thousands of miles away, discovering a kind of safety I have spent much of my life searching for.
I have known houses that were structurally sound and relationships that made me feel as though the walls might collapse at any moment.

I have known rooms where the doors locked securely, but where my body never stopped listening for footsteps.

I have known people who promised protection while teaching me that love could be withdrawn the moment I became inconvenient.

And so I built my own walls.

I studied the weather.

I became the Watchman.

I learned to survive in places where the world insisted I should have felt safe, but where something inside me knew better.
And now, almost impossibly, I have begun to recognize home in the tenderness of people living beneath a sky that has given them so little reason to feel safe themselves.

I want to be careful with that.

Because their world is not safe.

And the safety I feel in our relationship does not change the dangers they face.

I do not mistake their affection for protection against what surrounds them.

I do not confuse the home I have found in their love with the physical home and security they deserve.

Those are different things.

And both truths matter.
But I am beginning to understand that safety is not only the absence of danger.

There is also the safety of being welcomed.

Of being seen without being measured.

Of receiving affection without immediately wondering what it will cost.

Of discovering that another person’s kindness does not require us to repay it by disappearing into their needs.

And lately, something else has been happening.

Something quieter than all the grand revelations I once imagined healing would require.

We have begun spending hours simply existing beside one another.
Thousands of miles apart.

Sometimes someone is studying.

Sometimes I am writing.

Sometimes one of us is eating, or working, or listening to music.

We are not always talking.

We are not always doing anything that would seem remarkable to someone watching from outside our lives.

For so much of my life, I thought love was something I had to keep alive with my own two hands.

Something I had to tend constantly.

Something that might disappear if I stopped proving how much it mattered to me.
And now, sometimes, I look up from what I am doing and discover that it has been breathing beside me all along.

The simple pleasure of being together without needing every moment to become an event.

And somewhere in those ordinary hours, I noticed something opening.

Like a river that had been dammed for years and had finally found its way back to the sea.

And I realized that something had shifted.

Not in the distance between us.

Not in the uncertainty of tomorrow.

Not in the brightness of the sun outside my window.
The sunlight was no brighter than it had been the day before.

No more dim.

The world had not rearranged itself into something safer.

But somewhere inside me, the Watchman had taken up new directives.

Of his own.

No grand announcement.

No ceremony.

He simply reached for the fastenings of his breastplate.

And began to remove it.
I imagine that the little boy watched him closely.

He had never known the Watchman without his armor.

Never seen him approach the world without preparing to defend against it.

The breastplate had become so much a part of him that perhaps the boy had forgotten there was a person beneath it.

And yet, there he was.

Setting it down.

Not throwing it away.

Not declaring that danger had ceased to exist.

Simply placing it beside him.
And then the Watchman knelt.

Not toward the darkness.

Toward the boy.

And spoke so quietly that anyone standing farther away might have missed it.

But I heard him.

Dear boy.

I thought protecting you meant pointing out danger.

I thought it meant finding the inconsistencies before they could become betrayals.

I thought my work was to study every shadow, every change in the weather, every unfamiliar sound beyond the gate.

I believed that if I could recognize the danger quickly enough, I could keep you from ever being hurt again.
And I am sorry.

Because while I was teaching you how to recognize everything that might harm you, I sometimes forgot to show you everything that might love you.

I became so good at pointing toward the darkness that I forgot the light was there, too.

But I see it now.

And I think it is time for us to learn something new.

It is time to begin pointing out love, dear boy.

To notice the kindness.

The people who return.

The words that meet their actions.

The hands that offer without demanding.

The little moments in which somebody looks toward you simply because they are glad you are there.
I will still guide you when you need me.

I will still recognize danger.

I will still remind you when something deserves a closer look.

But I will no longer ask you to spend every beautiful moment searching for its ending.

And if difficult things happen, we will find our way through them.

We know how.

But perhaps the most important thing I have forgotten to tell you is that we do not have to do it alone.

Look around.

Look at the love.

Look at the light.
What you have been searching for is already here, in the middle of it.

And this time, dear boy, I want you to see it.

I imagine the boy standing very still.

Because for so many years, the Watchman had been the one who raised his voice.

The one who stood at the entrance to every dark possibility like Gandalf upon the bridge, staff lifted against whatever threatened to cross.

You shall not pass.

And the boy had loved him for it.

He had needed him.

There were nights when that fierce devotion had been the only thing standing between him and another terrible experience.
But now, for the first time, the Watchman was making a different declaration.

Not to an approaching monster.

Not to the darkness.

To the boy.

You may pass.

You may love.

You may receive.

You may live.

And perhaps that was the moment everything began to change.

Not because the walls were suddenly destroyed.

But because the Watchman no longer believed they needed to stand between the boy and every beautiful thing.
He reached toward the first stone.

And moved it.

Then another.

And another.

The boy watched as the familiar walls began to open.

He watched the old shadows retreat.

He watched the sunlight move across ground that had not felt its warmth in years.

And then, at last, the light reached him.

Directly.

Not filtered through fear.

Not broken apart by stone.

Not dimmed by the architecture of survival.

It fell straight onto his heart.
And the boy did something he had not always known how to do.

He stayed.

He did not run toward the light as though he might never see it again.

He did not reach for it with both hands, desperate to gather enough to survive another darkness.

He simply stood where he was.

And let it reach him.

Perhaps the Watchman smiled.

Perhaps he sat beside the boy.

Perhaps, for a while, neither of them needed to speak.

Because the boy was beginning to understand something that no amount of vigilance could have taught him.
That he could be loved while doing absolutely nothing to earn it.

While writing.

While studying.

While laughing.

While being quiet.

While simply existing.

And somewhere beneath another sky, someone might look up from his own life, find the boy’s grown self waiting there, and be glad.

I think about how long it has taken me to arrive at that possibility.

And I think about the strange, beautiful way it has arrived.

Through the people I love.
Through a family whose circumstances remain dangerously uncertain, yet whose tenderness has made room for me.

Through a father and son sharing one prayer mat.

Through a promised lesson in cooking.

Through a sentence about how a day begins.

And through the unfamiliar experience of realizing that I am not the only person keeping the light on.

Someone else is tending it, too.

I have spent so much of my life giving away the light I helped cultivate.

And somewhere along the way, I had mistaken that giving for the price of being allowed to belong.

But perhaps love was never meant to be a transaction of light.

Perhaps it was meant to be something we could share without either person being left in darkness.
I think about the little boy now.

About how long he waited for someone to make room for him without asking him to become something else first.

And I wish I could visit him.

I would take his hand.

I would bring him to the garden.

To the trees.

To the flowers.

To the three beehives humming with their small, miraculous labor.

I would show him the life that grew when he began keeping some of the sunlight for himself.
And then I would show him the screen.

The family beneath another sky.

The sunlight.

The son.

The father.

Their prayers.

The little moments of love that have become part of our ordinary days.

And I would tell him that one day, the Watchman would still be there.

But he would no longer need to stand guard over every beautiful thing.

He would learn that his work had never been only to recognize what might hurt the boy.

His work could also be to help him recognize what loves him.
And I think the boy would understand.

Perhaps not all at once.

Perhaps there would still be days when the old shadows looked familiar enough to frighten him.

Perhaps there would still be storms.

There will still be uncertainty.

There will still be moments when the Watchman needs to stand, when discernment matters, when protection is necessary.

But those moments will no longer be allowed to define every hour in between.

Because the Watchman has learned something.

Protection is not only warning someone about what can hurt them.

Sometimes protection is teaching them how to recognize what loves them.
And perhaps the most beautiful part is that none of this required the boy to stop being tender.

He did not have to become less generous.

He did not have to stop caring.

He did not have to harden himself against the world.

He simply had to discover that he was allowed to receive the very things he had spent his life giving away.

That love could arrive without a price.

That belonging could be offered without conditions.

That safety could sometimes mean allowing himself to be present without preparing for catastrophe.

And that there were people who might choose to remain beside him not because he was useful, but because they were glad he was there.
Today, the sun was shining.

It was not any brighter than yesterday.

It had not become more powerful.

It had not changed its position in the sky to accommodate the little boy’s longing.

But something inside the old fortress had changed.

The Watchman had laid down his breastplate.

The walls were opening.

And the boy was standing in the sunlight.

Not wondering when it would disappear.

Not searching for the shadow that would surely follow.

Simply allowing himself to feel its warmth.
I think, perhaps, this is what the tears were.

Not only grief.

Not only relief.

But the sound of a river beginning to move again.

The sound of a heart discovering that it had not forgotten how to receive.

And somewhere inside me, the Watchman was no longer shouting into the darkness.

He was sitting beside the boy.

Pointing toward the light.

Look, dear boy.

Do you see?

Someone is looking for you.

Someone is glad you answered.

Someone is making room.

And you do not have to earn it.
There was no moat.

No bridge.

No gate.

There was only the sunlight.

And the little boy who had spent so many years waiting for someone to let him through.

And this time, the Watchman did not stand in his way.

He took the boy’s hand.

And together, they stepped into the light.

Not because the darkness had disappeared.

But because, at last, they knew the light belonged to them, too.

Let the Light Travel Further

If these words have touched something in your heart, consider helping us bring warmth, food, and essential support to a family in Gaza.

Carry the Light Further