WHEN TINKER BELL CANNOT FLY

On the exhausting work of believing

CJ Sterling

A small boy at a dark window beneath an enormous indigo sky and a distant warm light.

When I was little,

I believed in magic.

Not the kind that made things disappear.

I was already learning

that things could disappear

without anyone waving a wand.

People.

Safety.

The ordinary assurances

that children are supposed

to inherit without questioning.

No.

I believed in a different kind of magic.

The kind that allowed

a frightened little boy

to lie awake in the darkness

and imagine

that somewhere,

somehow,

there was still something beautiful

waiting to be found.

I believed in second stars.

In fairy dust.

In wishing upon things

that were impossibly far away.

And I believed in Tinker Bell.

Especially that extraordinary moment

when the smallest light

begins to fade.

When believing

is no longer enough

to make her wings work.

And everyone is asked

to clap.

To believe.

To believe harder.

To give whatever they have left

to the possibility

that she might fly again.

As a child,

I thought that was beautiful.

As an adult,

I find myself wondering

about something

the story never really addressed.

What happens

when the people clapping

are exhausted, too?

What happens

when their hands hurt?

When they have been believing

for so long

that belief itself

has begun to feel

like something

they can no longer carry?

And what happens

when Tinker Bell

simply cannot fly?

Even when everyone

loves her enough

to wish that she could?

I spent fifteen years

sitting across from people

who were trying

to survive things

they had once believed

would destroy them.

There were stories

that could barely be spoken.

Grief that had no language.

Bodies that had learned

to anticipate danger

long after the danger

was supposed to have passed.

And people who had become

so accustomed to disappointment

that hope itself

felt threatening.

I understood them.

More than I often said.

And somewhere

between the science

and the suffering,

I became fascinated

by belief.

Not as a substitute

for reality.

But as one of the ways

human beings experience it.

There is a peculiar word

we sometimes use

when discussing the relationship

between expectation

and the body.

Placebo.

People often hear that word

and think it means imaginary.

As though a change

in someone's experience

must be less real

because expectation

played some part in it.

But I have never found

the human mind

quite so easy

to dismiss.

I have seen people

discover capacities

they had stopped believing

they possessed.

I have watched

the possibility of tomorrow

become meaningful again

to someone

who could scarcely imagine

surviving the afternoon.

And I have learned

that there are things

a person can know

with tremendous intellectual certainty

that their frightened body

has not yet learned

how to believe.

Of course,

belief has limits.

It does not replace food.

It does not replace medicine.

It cannot make danger

less dangerous

simply because

we wish it away.

A warm window shines across a rain-darkened garden.

But I have never believed

that understanding

the limits of something

requires us

to deny its beauty.

I understand

what happens

when a frightened person

hears a familiar voice.

And still,

I believe there is magic

in being told,

I'm here.

Today,

someone I love

was having a difficult time.

There are days

when the world asks

more of a human being

than any human being

should be required to give.

Days when exhaustion

becomes something deeper

than tiredness.

When the body

begins to tell the story

the mouth

has been trying

so desperately

not to speak.

I could see it.

The trembling.

The tenderness.

The way even ordinary moments

seemed to require

an extraordinary amount

of courage.

And the part of me

that spent so many years

as a clinician

recognized what I was witnessing.

The watchman in me

recognized something else.

He noticed

how much of the suffering

had nothing to do

with what was happening

inside the person.

How much belonged

to circumstances

no amount of tenderness

could make acceptable.

And the part of me

that loves—

Oh.

That part.

That part wanted

to reach through the distance

and gather every frightened piece

into my arms.

Not to repair anything.

Not to make the sadness disappear.

Just to hold.

To make somewhere

for the trembling

to finally stop

having to explain itself.

But distance

is a peculiar kind

of helplessness.

Especially when the world

has become so unpredictable

that even the ordinary privilege

of remaining connected

cannot be trusted.

Sometimes,

the most intimate thing

two people can offer

one another

is their presence.

And sometimes,

even that

is interrupted.

I have spent much of my life

being the person

who remembers

where the light switch is.

I learned young.

On.

Off.

On.

I needed to know

that darkness

wasn't necessarily permanent.

That something could disappear

and still return.

And over the years,

I became quite skilled

at reminding other people

of the same possibility.

I learned how to stand

beside another person's storm

without demanding

that the clouds disappear.

I learned how to recognize

the smallest signs

of a returning sunrise.

I learned how to say,

I know you cannot see the road.

But I can see a little farther.

And for now,

perhaps you can borrow

some of what I see.

Small sheltered flames beside dark water beneath an overhanging rock.

There were years

when I believed

I was handing out matches

from a box

that would eventually become empty.

And there were years

when I was terribly afraid

that it already had.

But lately,

I've begun to understand

something different.

Sometimes light

is not a possession

we surrender.

Sometimes it is something

we discover

between us.

A flame held near another flame.

A small warmth

that makes it possible

to remember

what warmth feels like.

Not one person

saving another.

Not one person

responsible

for keeping the entire sky illuminated.

Just two people

making room

for one another's light.

Even when one

has become very faint.

Today,

I watched a light eclipse.

More than once.

And I want to tell you

what I did.

Because once upon a time,

I might have believed

that love required me

to make the darkness stop.

To find the right words.

To summon the right smile.

To make the frightened person

feel better

so that I could know

I had done enough.

But that is not

what love asked of me today.

I did not try

to make the light shine.

I did not ask it

to become brighter.

I did not mistake

its exhaustion

for a failure

to be beautiful.

I stayed.

And I offered

the same amount of love

that had been there

when the laughter came easily.

The same tenderness.

The same belief

in the extraordinary life

that still deserves

to be lived.

And when there was room,

I spoke about tomorrow.

Not in grand declarations.

Not in promises

I have no power to guarantee.

But in little pictures.

Ordinary mornings.

Coffee.

Sunlight through a window.

The wonderful possibility

of having nothing urgent

to be afraid of.

The kind of future

that would sound

almost disappointingly ordinary

to someone

who has never had to wonder

whether ordinary life

would be permitted.

And for a little while,

something softened.

Not everything.

Not the circumstances.

Not the terrible uncertainty

waiting beyond the conversation.

But there was room

for another feeling.

A little warmth

beside the fear.

And I realized

that perhaps this

was what I had been trying

to understand

about belief

all these years.

Believing is a verb.

I have written

those words before.

I believed them

when I wrote them.

I believe them still.

But today,

I discovered

how much that verb

can ask of a person.

Because sometimes

believing

is not a beautiful feeling.

Sometimes it does not

come with certainty.

Sometimes there is

no rush of inspiration.

No sudden lifting

of the heart.

No fairy dust.

Sometimes believing

is emotionally exhausting.

Sometimes it feels

like running

with lungs

that have already

begun to burn.

Sometimes the wings

are so terribly tired

that even remembering

how to fly

feels impossible.

And still—

there is the choice

to keep making room

for tomorrow.

Not because tomorrow

has promised us anything.

But because the people

we love

deserve to know

that we can still imagine

them living inside it.

And because

on the days

when someone cannot

carry their own hope,

perhaps we can hold

a little of it

beside them.

Not forever.

Not as an obligation.

Not as proof

that our love

will be powerful enough

to change the world.

But as an offering.

Here.

I know today is frightening.

I know you are tired.

I know you cannot see

what I am seeing.

But I have saved

a little picture

of tomorrow for you.

Would you like

to look at it with me?

And I need

to tell the truth

about something else.

Today,

my own light

grew faint.

I could feel it.

Not because

I stopped loving.

Not because

I stopped believing.

But because

there is a particular

kind of exhaustion

that comes

from loving someone

through circumstances

you cannot change.

The heart

keeps reaching.

The mind

keeps watching.

The body

keeps listening

for the smallest

change in the weather.

A plain folded T-shirt rests on a weathered outdoor bench beside dark water.

And somewhere

between the watchfulness

and the tenderness,

an old phrase

came back to me.

Emotional cardio.

I used to say it

all the time

in the rooms

where we did

the difficult work

of healing.

So often, in fact,

that at one point

we even had T-shirts.

The people I worked with

loved that phrase.

And I think

I understand why.

Because it named

something

we were all discovering.

That healing

is not always

a beautiful revelation.

Sometimes

it is practice.

Repetition.

The courage

to try again

when the last attempt

was exhausting.

The willingness

to keep showing up

for a life

you are still learning

how to believe

you deserve.

Not because

the pain is imaginary.

Not because

the work is easy.

But because

some of the most

extraordinary changes

in a human life

begin with the smallest,

most difficult

acts of participation.

We called it

emotional cardio.

And we practiced.

Together.

Sometimes

the work was exhausting.

Sometimes

it was beautiful.

And sometimes,

the most important thing

we could do

was recognize

how much effort

it had taken

simply to begin.

And today,

all these years later,

I found myself

reaching for those words

again.

Not as a clinician

explaining a concept.

Not as someone

trying to help

another person

find their courage.

But as a human being

whose own heart

was becoming tired.

And I almost laughed.

Because there it was.

The language

we had carried

through so many

difficult afternoons.

Returning to me

when I needed it.

Emotional cardio.

Not a new discovery.

An old practice.

One I had spent

a lifetime learning.

And one I was

still learning

how to live.

Sometimes,

that practice

is a kind of endurance.

Not the heroic kind

people applaud.

The quiet kind.

The kind nobody sees.

The kind that happens

when you are alone

after the conversation ends

and the room

has become very still.

When you are frightened.

When you are tired.

When you know

the darkness is real.

And nevertheless,

you refuse

to let it become

the only thing

you are willing

to believe in.

Which brings me

back to Tinker Bell.

I think,

if I could return

to that story now,

I would change

one small thing.

I would still clap.

Of course I would.

I have spent

my whole life

clapping for little lights

that were trying

desperately

not to go out.

But if she could not fly,

I would stop.

Not because

I had stopped believing.

A tiny warm glow rests in a broad leaf sheltered from rain.

But because

I would finally understand

that perhaps

she did not need

another person

asking her

to lift herself

into the sky.

Perhaps

she needed

somewhere gentle

to land.

A hand.

A shoulder.

A quiet place

where being loved

did not depend

on being luminous.

And perhaps

the real magic

would not be

watching her

begin to fly again.

Perhaps

it would be

watching her

finally rest.

Without fear

that anyone

would love her less.

I wonder

how many of us

have mistaken

our exhaustion

for the loss

of our faith.

How many

have looked

at our trembling hands

and decided

we must no longer

believe strongly enough.

How many

have been told

to keep hoping

when what we needed

was someone

to sit beside us

and say,

You can rest.

I'll remember

what the sky looks like

for a little while.

And I wonder

what might happen

if we stopped

requiring hope

to feel hopeful.

If we allowed belief

to be quiet.

If we understood

that courage

does not always

look like standing.

Sometimes

it looks like

remaining tender.

Sometimes

it looks like

speaking of tomorrow

without pretending

today is anything

other than difficult.

And sometimes

it looks like

letting someone

love you

when your own wings

have become

too tired to move.

I don't know

what tomorrow brings.

I have spent

a lifetime

trying to read

the last page first.

But I am learning

to leave some pages

unopened.

I know

there will be days

when the sky is dark.

I know

there will be moments

when the people

I love

cannot find

their own light.

And I know

there will be evenings

when mine

is scarcely visible.

But perhaps

that is not

the end of belief.

Perhaps

that is where

its gentlest form

begins.

Not in the certainty

that we will never

be afraid.

Not in the promise

that every wish

will come true.

But in the willingness

to sit beside

another human being

beneath an enormous,

uncertain sky

and say,

I see the darkness.

I know.

You don't have

to pretend

it isn't there.

And I am still here.

I still believe

there is more

of your story

worth living.

And until

you can imagine it

again,

there is room

for that dream

beside me.

So perhaps

the question

is not whether

we still believe

in magic.

Perhaps

the question is:

What do we do

when the magic

becomes difficult

to feel?

Can we remain

beside someone

without asking them

to become brighter?

Can we love

without making

their hopefulness

a condition

of our own tenderness?

And when

our own wings

grow tired—

will we allow

ourselves

to be held

with the same gentleness

we have spent

our lives

offering others?

Tonight,

I am thinking

about a little boy

who once lay awake

in the darkness,

making enormous wishes

upon distant stars.

He did not know

what would become

of his life.

He did not know

how often

the lights

would go out.

But he kept

reaching for the switch.

On.

Off.

On.

Sunlight and a crescent moon share the sky above a distant figure.

And somehow,

after everything,

he grew into

someone who still

looks toward the sky.

Someone who still

believes

that even the smallest light

is worth finding.

Someone who has learned

that the Sun

does not stop

being the Sun

when clouds

move across his face.

And the Moon

does not stop

belonging to the sky

because the night

has become

terribly long.

So tonight,

I will not demand

that Tinker Bell

fly.

I will make

a place for her

to rest.

I will let

my own wings

be tired, too.

And when

the darkness comes,

as it sometimes does,

A lone figure watches the first possibility of dawn over a dark sea.

I will remember

that believing

was never a promise

that the night

could not hurt us.

Sometimes

it was simply

the extraordinary decision

to leave a little room

for the possibility

of morning.

And to love

one another

while we wait.

We are still here.

And we are still looking up.